Troy Planning Commission Approves Demolition Request for Downtown Tavern Building – WHIO TV 7 and WHIO Radio

TROY – The Troy Planning Commission has approved the request to demolish the Tavern building in downtown Troy. The building was damaged in the January 2020 tornado.

It has been a matter of division in the community for over a year.

The planning commission does not usually consider public comment, but allowed this in this case as well as significant input from the people of Troy throughout the process. Owner Randy Kimmel of 116 West Main LLC first filed for demolition in September 2020. It was a long process for the commission to try to find the best outcome. One of the biggest issues for those who oppose a possible demolition is what would happen to the space in the historic district of Troy.

“The staff’s first recommendation goes on to cite staff’s opinion that raising the structure and not replacing it will leave an obvious void in the streetscape,” said Alan Kappers, Chairman of the Commission of planning for Troy. “The Planning Commission should demand a rescue plan that meets all of the requirements in the above section with new construction that meets architectural design standards as a condition for demolition. I agree with the first recommendation. The minimum reuse plan submitted with the request is in my opinion adequate.

In 2020, there was a rally to save the Main Street building. At one point, the cost of repairs and renovations was estimated at $ 4.1 million in March 2021, according to the city staff report. Another estimate was made last month and it is expected to cost around $ 3.2 million. According to an estimate by Bruns General Contracting, the cost to meet minimum building code standards would be around $ 659,788.

“Based on the fact that the claimant has provided adequate evidence of substantial economic hardship providing clear evidence of at least two conditions which outweigh the historic architectural and cultural value of the tavern building,” said Ed Westmeyer , member of the Troy Planning Commission.

The building is not listed in the National Register of Historic Places. There is a plaque from the Troy Historical Society, displayed on the building in 1969, which indicates that parts of the building were part of the courthouses and prisons of Troy. Preserve historic elements such as the plaque and ensure that the common walls of buildings on either side are left in good condition.

“The rescue plan will include the restoration of the site with landscaping consisting of seed and straw or sod until in the future the owner comes before the planning committee with further site improvements requested. “said Westmeyer.

Approval of the demolition request does not guarantee that the building will be demolished. However, the building is under the orders of the Miami County Development Department to resolve “unsafe conditions related to public safety.” Earlier this month, the Troy-Miami County Public Library Board of Trustees voted to bid on the building.

The commission learned on September 28 that there was a contract to buy the building in order to put a boutique hotel in its place. The demolition of the existing brick structure built in 1840 and 1902 is a condition of sale by the party exploring the purchase.

The future of the building is still uncertain.

Source link

About Joshua M. Osborne

Check Also

How do you do teen comedies today? Buy a high school.

Chris Weitz, the co-director of “American Pie” and one of the producers of Ms. Cohen’s …